Proposal to keep Greta mural denied by council

By Simon Ruppert

A last minute push by the Benalla Sustainable Future Group to keep the controversial Greta Thunberg mural displayed on the Benalla Rural City Council building has ultimately failed

Benalla Rural City Council did not change its stance on the artwork - and it was removed on Tuesday morning.

The group put its proposal in wiring to council last week.

In that document they asked that council "exercise their discretion to allow the image of Greta Thunberg to remain on the window of the council customer service centre".

Greta Thunberg portrait removed

“We view this painting as a powerful statement - that here is a community that cares, not only about the present wellbeing of its citizens, but the future as well,” the letter read.

“Greta is a beacon of hope for millions of people, both young and old, around the world, and a hero for them as she challenges the world's leaders to take immediate and urgent action to mitigate climate change.

“Climate change action is not a political issue, as some would have us believe.

The artwork was vandalised at one point - which ironically meant it stayed up longer than planned

“It is an environmental, social, economic and ethical issue, and we are right now experiencing one of the most devastating effects predicted long ago by climate scientists, as a result of the warming and drying of our part of the Earth.

“We need to take a stand on the issue of climate change, and what better way can there be for council to demonstrate their support for action, than to leave Greta's image on the window.”

Future group president Peter Holmes said the group was "extremely disappointed" with council's response.

Devenish community throws support behind bush-fire charities

“In (the response) they simply reiterated that the painting was part of the Window to Window Festival, and would be removed this week,” Mr Holmes said.

“None of the reasons the future group offered in the letter to council were addressed in their response, and (I hope) that this is not indicative of council's attitude towards addressing the issue of mitigating climate change.

“Seven years ago, I was part of a community consultation group, organised by council, to develop a Climate Change Adaptation Plan.

A crowd gathered to watch Tim Bowtell restore the painting after it was vandalised

“Back then, we were probably thinking that the world had until about 2050 to make things right.

“Well, things have changed drastically, even in that short space of time, with temperature records being broken virtually every year, rainfall decreasing significantly, and now Australia is in the grip of a wildfire crisis that has cost at least 26 lives directly, burnt (more than) 10 million hectares of forest and farmland, destroyed (more than) 2000 homes and many more buildings, and killed an estimated 500 million creatures, many to the point of extinction.”

Fill an esky to support fire affected communities

“BSFG (thinks) that there is no longer room in our parliaments or local governments for debate about whether climate change is real.

“The discussion and the action must now be about urgently mitigating the causes of climate change, and not about papering over the cracks every time we experience another disaster.

“This discussion must be bipartisan and above party political motives.”

Mr Holmes indicated the future group believes, along with many others in the community, that an excellent way for Benalla Rural City to respond, is to declare that there is a climate emergency (as have 85 other local government councils in Australia).

“Council should then convene a group of community leaders from business, health, energy, transport, environment, and most importantly, youth sectors, to work with council officers to develop and implement initiatives that will rapidly make BRCC a zero-emissions community, and therefore make a major contribution to the mitigation of the worst effects of climate change.”