Responding to the release of the interim review of the Water Act 2007, Mrs Dalton said the findings expose significant flaws in water governance despite the review's conclusion that the legislation's foundations remain sound.
“I’m saying they’re not,” Mrs Dalton said.
She said the review admits that water governance lacks transparency, government accountability is fragmented and ineffective, environmental water is not delivering its full potential, and the economic impacts on small irrigation communities can be hidden within broader Basin-wide assessments."
Mrs Dalton questioned how such findings could be reconciled with an assessment that the Act’s foundations remain effective.
She argued that after nearly 20 years, billions of dollars and endless reviews, we’re still left with struggling farming communities, questionable environmental outcomes and an army of bureaucrats.
According to Mrs Dalton, the review also fails to adequately recognise water recovery programs as a key factor contributing to economic hardship in irrigation-dependent communities.
“The system cannot investigate itself and deliver the truth,” she said, describing the review process as another bureaucratic exercise that does little to address the concerns of people living and working in Basin communities.
Mrs Dalton said a Federal Royal Commission was needed to provide an independent examination of the Murray-Darling Basin Plan and its impacts.
She pointed to the New South Wales Parliament’s unanimous support for a Royal Commission into water management, with the power to compel evidence, follow the money and hold decision-makers accountable.
“Our towns deserve a Royal Commission, not another review,” Mrs Dalton said.
The interim review is expected to inform future discussions about the operation of the Water Act and the long-term management of the Murray-Darling Basin.