A lobby group spokesperson said community concerns over the current works in Mair St had prompted a committee of locals to initiate proceedings in VCAT challenging council’s actions.
“(We have outlined) several important planning grounds ... identified in the VCAT challenge,” the spokesperson said.
- Whether the café and cinema together are legal in the zone;
- A lack of the relevant planning permit, including a heritage assessment and approval; and
- Uncertainty over flooding issues being addressed.
“Other serious concerns include council’s refusal to provide a business plan to the community; Inadequate or any consideration of Aboriginal heritage issues; cost blowouts from $1 million to $3 million with no explanation or a projected final cost; and a lack of community consultation on the current project,” the spokesperson said.
The VCAT challenge was Initiated by Benalla locals Jane Rushworth and David Blore.
“(The) costs to register the VCAT challenge have been met by a small group of concerned residents who are prepared to put their money where their mouths are,” Ms Rushworth said.
“A Go Fund Me page has been established to encourage other concerned citizens to provide support to this challenge.
“Without a business case and risk analysis, how can the Benalla community be confident we are not creating a huge liability which ratepayers will be burdened with in the future?
“Aside from the unsuitability of building on a floodplain, many believe the current BPACC facility should remain operational instead of building a new facility.”
The first hearing at VCAT was held on Friday, September 16, and a second will be held later in the month. A further hearing will be held in November.
“The community group ... is backed by extensive documentation highlighting the many shortcomings of council’s proposals,” Ms Rushworth said.
“The aim is to stop the construction of the cinema and cafe, while allowing the improvements for the Historical Society and Museum, and Visitor Information Centre.”
Mr Blore said he believed council had so far refused to listen to the community and seem determined to push ahead in the face of major and serious concerns.
“This challenge, if upheld, will provide an opportunity for council to finally undertake an effective community consultation on what should be provided on this site, and do a proper evaluation of our needs.”
Benalla Rural City Council Mayor Bernie Hearn was contacted for comment.
“Council is unable to comment at this stage as this matter is currently before the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal,” Cr Hearn said.
However in July 2021, then Mayor, Cr Danny Claridge, spoke to the Ensign regarding the development, which was partly driven by the cinema in BPACC becoming financially unviable.
“The BPACC cinema, which has a capacity of 344, has an average attendance of just 26 people per screening,“ Cr Claridge said at the time.
Cr Claridge also said another issue was that in 2018, when council's contract with GOTAFE to operate BPACC expired it was GOTAFE that decided against renewing the management agreement.
“When we lost the management agreement with GOTAFE we also lost funding from them, and Creative Victoria, which amounted to about $140,000 per year,” Cr Claridge said in 2021.
“Without that, ratepayers would have to pick up the shortfall — and the BPACC Cinema was already losing money despite having that extra $140,000 per year.
“From that period on we started to look at what we could do to provide a cinema for the community if BPACC was not suitable.”
Speaking to the Ensign earlier in the month Cr Hearn did address concerns over planning permission on the site.
“A planning permit for the Visitor Information Centre and Costume Museum redevelopment was not required,” Cr Hearn said on September 5.
“In October 2021, to facilitate the development of land by or on behalf of municipal councils, the Victorian Government amended Victorian Planning Provisions to exempt councils from obtaining a planning permit for developments with an estimated cost of less than $10,000,000.”